The Constitutional Court of Bosnia and Herzegovina held its 176th plenary session on 19 and 20 November 2026, and decided on requests for abstract constitutional review, a review of compatibility of the law with the Constitution of Bosnia and Herzegovina and the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, a number of appeals, and requests for interim measures.
Of the decisions adopted at the plenary session, the Constitutional Court singles out the following:
U-16/22 – In this case, the Constitutional Court decided on the request of Željko Komšić, member of the Presidency of Bosnia and Herzegovina at the time of filing request, for a review of constitutionality of Chapter IV(4) – Article 17 of the Constitution of the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina, paragraph 2, indents 1, 3, 4, 5, 8 and 9 of Amendment XXXVII to the Constitution of the FBiH and paragraph 1, sub-paragraph 1 of Amendment XXXVIII to the Constitution of the FBiH, the part of Amendment LXXVII supplementing Chapter V(1), Article 70, paragraph 5, indents 1, 3, 4, 5, 8 and 9 of the Constitution of the Republika Srpska and the part of Amendment LXXXII supplementing Article 70, sub-indent (a), paragraph 1 of the Constitution of the RS, with regard to their compatibility with Articles I(2), III(3)(b), II(2) and II(4) of the Constitution of Bosnia and Herzegovina, in conjunction with Article 7 of the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination, Article 25 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and Article 1 of Protocol No. 12 to the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms. Allegations of the applicant, in substance, are confined in three assertions: 1. that the category of Others has been discriminated because in the House of Peoples and the Council of Peoples it participates only in majority decision-making, without invoking the mechanism for the protection of vital national interests; 2. that the lists of vital national interests are too broadly defined and make it possible for every issue to be qualified as destructive to the vital national interest of a constituent people; 3. that the legislative process is regulated differently in the two Entities since in the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina every decision and every law must also be adopted by the House of Peoples, whereas in Republika Srpska this is required only in respect of matters deemed to necessitate the protection of a vital national interest.
With regard to the first assertion, the Constitutional Court pointed out that the institute of the protection of vital national interests was not designed as individual right, but as a mechanism used in states characterised by social diversity to prevent the domination of one community over another. In this model, certain protective mechanisms are not necessarily available to all citizens or collectivities under equal conditions, but are instead linked to the communities that form the basis of the constitutional compromise – in the present case, the constituent peoples. The Constitutional Court concludes that this constitutes a “right specifically granted to an individual under national law” and that Article 1 of Protocol No. 12 to the European Convention is applicable. The Constitutional Court also pointed out that it is up to the constitutional legislator to change the system if it is no longer considered adequate more than thirty years after the war; but it is not for the Constitutional Court to change it.
When examining the allegations that the lists of vital national interests are defined too broadly, the Constitutional Court recalled that in the process of constitutional review it is not for the Constitutional Court to determine whether the existing legislative framework governing vital national interests is the best possible solution or whether a different solution would be fairer and better. The Constitutional Court considers that the issues defined as constituting vital national interests are sufficiently clearly defined and are of a quality appropriate to a democratic system, and therefore do not call into question the principle of the rule of law under Article I(2) of the Constitution of BiH. The Constitutional Court also accepts that the mechanism for the protection of vital national interests may also be invoked in respect of issues that clearly do not fall within the scope of the vital national interest of a constituent people. However, every legal mechanism is susceptible to abuse in practice. Nevertheless, the manner in which the mechanism for the protection of vital national interests is implemented, and any potential abuses thereof, cannot lead to the conclusion that this mechanism is per se contrary to the principle of the rule of law under Article I(2) of the Constitution of BiH.
With regard to the allegations that the legislative process is regulated differently in the two Entities, the Constitutional Court notes that potential differences in Entity constitutions, in themselves, cannot raise the issue of discrimination in a situation where the request contains no other arguments, nor can it be concluded that the contested provisions are manifestly discriminatory. The Constitutional Court pointed out that in both Entities, constituent peoples are able to utilize the mechanism for the protection of vital national interests; therefore, the fact that in the Federation of BiH every law must also be adopted by the House of Peoples, unlike in the Republika Srpska, contrary to the applicant's allegations, does not mean that the constituent peoples are not afforded the same level of protection of vital national interests.
Finally, the Constitutional Court established that the Amendments to the Constitution of the Federation of BiH and the Republika Srpska were contested under Articles I(2), II(2), II(4) and III(3)(b) of the Constitution of Bosnia and Herzegovina, Article 1 of Protocol No. 12 to the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, Article 7 of the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination and Article 25 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.
U-17/26 – Deciding on the request by Denis Bećirović, the Chair of the Presidency of BiH at the time of filing the request, the Constitutional Court finds that there is a dispute between Bosnia and Herzegovina and the Republika Srpska in connection with the Declaration by Željka Cvijanović, Member of the Presidency of Bosnia and Herzegovina, declaring Decision of the Presidency of Bosnia and Herzegovina on the appointment of members of the Commission to Preserve National Monuments, adopted without consensus at the 30th meeting of the Presidency of Bosnia and Herzegovina held on 29 June 2026, to be very destructive of a vital interest of the Republika Srpska no. 04-50-1-1749-14/26 of 1 July 2026 and Decision of the National Assembly of the Republika Srpska on confirming the declaration of the Member of the Presidency of Bosnia and Herzegovina from the Republika Srpska no. 02/1-021-890/26 of 7 July 2026. The Constitutional Court established that the aforesaid declaration and Decision of the National Assembly of the Republika Srpska on confirming the declaration of the Member of the Presidency of Bosnia and Herzegovina from the Republika Srpska are not compatible with Article V(2)(d) of the Constitution of Bosnia and Herzegovina. The Constitutional Court found that the disputed Declaration and the disputed Decision were adopted beyond the constitutional requirements of Article V(2)(d) of the Constitution of BiH, and pursuant to Article 61(1) of the Rules of the Constitutional Court of Bosnia and Herzegovina, rendered them ineffective in their entirety, whereby they cease to have effect. Consequently, the Decision on Appointment of the Commission no. 01-50-1-1749-3/26 of 29 June 2026, adopted by the Presidency of BiH without consensus, has not ceased to be valid and remains in legal force.
U-20/26 – In this case, the Constitutional Court decided on a request by eleven members of the House of Representatives of the Parliamentary Assembly of Bosnia and Herzegovina, Denis Bećirović, the Chair of the Presidency of Bosnia and Herzegovina at the time of filing the requests, and Denis Zvizdić, the First Deputy Chair of the House of Representatives of the Parliamentary Assembly of Bosnia and Herzegovina at the time of filing the requests, for constitutional review of Article 359(b) of the Criminal Code of the Republika Srpska. The contested provision of Article 359(b) of the Criminal Code of the Republika Srpska, (Official Gazette of the RS, 64/17, 104/18 – Decision of the Constitutional Court of the Republika Srpska, 15/21, 89/21, www.ohr.int – Decision of the High Representative no. 12/23, Official Gazette of the RS, 73/23, Official Gazette of Bosnia and Herzegovina, 9/24 – Decision of the Constitutional Court of Bosnia and Herzegovina, Official Gazette of the RS, 105/24 – Decision of the Constitutional Court of the Republika Srpska, 19/25, 31/25, Official Gazette of Bosnia and Herzegovina, 36/25 - Decision of the Constitutional Court of Bosnia and Herzegovina, Official Gazette of the RS, 85/25 - Decision of the Constitutional Court of the Republika Srpska, 92/25 – Law Repealing the Laws, 25/26 and 78/26), criminalises the public display and promotion of flags and symbols of the Army of the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina. The Constitutional Court found that Article 359b of the Criminal Code of the Republika is not compatible with Articles I(2) and III(3)(b) of the Constitution of Bosnia and Herzegovina. In the reasons for its decision, the Constitutional Court, inter alia, pointed out that the contested provision is incompatible with the laws pertaining to the use of official symbols and insignia of members of the Armed Forces of Bosnia and Herzegovina, which govern the use of official symbols and insignia of the Army of RBiH. The regulations of the RBiH on the design and use of the symbols of Army of RBiH continue to operate in force within the territory of Bosnia and Herzegovina by reason of the constitutional principle of continuity recognised under Article I(1) of the Constitution of BiH in respect of the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina read together with paragraph 2 of Annex II to the Constitution of BiH. The RS National Assembly lacks the competence to determine the discontinuation of the legal acts of the institutions of Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina, whose continuity has been constitutionally recognized. The contested provision is thus incompatible with Article III(3)(b) of the Constitution of BiH interpreted in light of the principle of continuation of laws, as it undermines the normative hierarchy unequivocally established by Article III(3)(b) of the Constitution of BiH through the harmonisation of legal regulations within the legal system in accordance with their hierarchy, in which the state laws must be harmonious with decisions of the institutions of Bosnia and Herzegovina. Furthermore, by decisions of institutions of Bosnia and Herzegovina, the Army of RBiH forms part of the Armed Forces of Bosnia and Herzegovina, together with its military heritage and identity, including its distinctive insignia, the display of which is a duty for the respective infantry regiments. The contested provision is thus also incompatible with Article I(2) of the Constitution of BiH, as it violates the decisions of the institutions of Bosnia and Herzegovina requiring regiments to wear the insignia of their respective regiment.
AP-4497/24 – In this case, the Constitutional Court concluded that there is a violation of the principle of legal certainty, which constitutes a core principle of the rule of law under the right to a fair trial guaranteed by Article II(3)(e) of the Constitution of Bosnia and Herzegovina and Article 6(1) of the European Convention. This violation arises as the Cantonal Court in Sarajevo, as a court of final instance whose decision could not be challenged by any effective statutory remedy on that specific matter, delivered a diametrically opposed judgment in a case sharing the same or similar factual and legal basis with previous cases, without offering an objective and reasonable explanation for its departure. Furthermore, in accordance with the case-law of the Constitutional Court, the appellants lacked access to an efficient and effective mechanism for harmonising inconsistent case-law.
All decisions adopted at the plenary session will be delivered to the applicants/appellants within one month and published as soon as possible on the website of the Constitutional Court of BiH.